Sunday, November 15, 2026

“Risks” — Rev. Brent Gundlah

First Reading (1 Thessalonians 5:1-11/NRSVUE)
Gospel Reading (Matthew 25:14-30/NRSVUE)

Jesus tells a bunch of really strange stories in Matthew’s Gospel, and the one you just heard — the Parable of the Talents — definitely falls into that category. Just when we think we have one of these stories figured out, the meaning we thought they had can slip right through our fingers. And if we revisit them with open hearts and open minds from time to time, new questions inevitably arise and confound whatever understanding of them we might have had.

This story seems simple enough on the surface (as many of Jesus’s parables do): A slaveowner heads off on a journey, distributing portions of his fortune amongst three of his slaves, entrusting each of them with a piece of his fortune allocated in proportion to how well he believes they can handle managing it based upon their respective abilities.

The master returns some time later and finds that two of the slaves have taken some risks with all this money and, as a result, have managed to double it; and for this their master commends them. The third chooses instead to bury his money in the ground, doing absolutely nothing else with it during the master’s absence.

When the master returns looking for an explanation for the third slave’s inaction he explains that he was afraid of his master, whom he saw as a harsh and unforgiving man — one who came by his fortune by taking what was earned on the backs of others. For his laziness, the third slave is condemned to the “outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth,” which sounds really nice.

Okay, I think I get it (or at least I thought I did anyway). The slaveowner is meant to represent God, who has given us gifts (be they money or special abilities or whatever) in varying degrees that we are supposed to use do God’s work in our world, until Jesus returns to grant us all the gift of eternal life.

The first two slaves take some risks with the master’s treasure in his absence and are rewarded for doing so. The third slave is so afraid of the master that he simply buries the share he has been given. He apparently takes no risk and is punished severely for this by the master upon his return.

Unsurprisingly, this parable has become the inspiration for many stewardship sermons, which tend to go something like this: God gives us all treasure and talents that we are supposed to use to do God’s work in the world. To utilize these gifts — and to work to multiply them — is the virtuous response to God’s generosity. To hide them away in fear is most definitely not. God will judge us for the faithfulness with which we rise to this responsibility. So get out your checkbooks, throw on that apron, grab that spatula or saxophone or shovel or whatever you’ve got to offer with and get to it!

And in and of itself, this message is okay, I suppose. The church really does need all of these things to do God’s work in the world. And we shouldn’t hoard our gifts for ourselves, but rather use them for the benefit of others. But I’m not so sure that this is all Jesus is saying here.

First, let’s clear up some misconceptions about this story. A “talent” in this context is not what we think of as being today; it isn’t the ability to sing, or to tap dance, or to play the cello, or to do math in your head. In the ancient world a talent was a denomination of money.

But a talent wasn’t a shiny nickel or a silver dollar or even a crisp hundred dollar bill; a single talent was a whole lot of dough. As biblical scholar John Dominic Crossan explains it:

“A talent of gold weighed about thirty pounds and was worth about six thousand denari — with a single denarius representing a laborer’s daily pay. In ancient terms, the revenues from [Herod’s] domains in Galilee and Perea were about two hundred talents. In modern terms, that first slave had just received two million dollars.”

I tell you all this to emphasize just how much each of these slaves was given by their master — even the one who was presented with a single talent. Jesus is using absurdly large amounts of money to make a really big point here, and that point is this: just how much are we willing to risk for God?

Again, I am definitely not trying to sell short all that we bring to share with our church communities and with the world. These things are important, and I can virtually guarantee that Jesus would think they were important too. Even though I am always leery of speaking for Jesus, I’m pretty sure about this one. And I definitely understand this traditional reading of this story.

But remember that Jesus is trying to convey some essential truths about God’s kingdom and our relationship to it through this parable — and the enormity of God’s kingdom is always far beyond our ability to comprehend it. So perhaps we’d be well served by looking at this story with fresh eyes, by not so easily giving into the temptation to fill-in all of the blanks, and by not assuming we know all of the answers (or that we ever will living here in our world).

Throughout the centuries, that third slave has taken a lot of flack for his seemingly timid actions. But what if he is actually the boldest of them all?

We are told at the beginning of the story that the master is heading off on a journey. We don’t know why he is leaving, we don’t know where he is going, and we don’t know for how long he will be gone. We have no reason — at least from what the story actually tells us — to think that he will ever be coming back.

And if this is the case, then the first two slaves — who are typically described as the good ones, the ones who do what they are supposed to do — don’t necessarily look that gutsy. Sure, they took their master’s money and turned it into more money, but did they really have anything to lose if they never envisioned their master returning in order to settle-up with them?

Did they really think all along that the money was still their master’s or did they see things differently? The story doesn’t say at the outset whether there was ever any expectation of repayment. I can’t help but believe that those first two slaves were really surprised when the master showed-up again looking for his money. Did they thank their lucky stars that they hadn’t lost it all?

As the story begins, the first two slaves don’t really seem to have much skin in the game; they’re playing with house money and they seem to act accordingly. It makes me think of those times on the game show, “Who Wants to Be a Millionaire,” when a contestant who’s already won a bunch of money, bets it all on the next question and ends up losing most of what they’d won. They’re disappointed for sure, but most just shrug their shoulders and say something like, “Well, I’m still leaving with more than I had when I started.” It may seem like the contestant risked a lot, but their cavalier reaction underscores the fact that they really didn’t have much on the line at all.

And if they were to actually win, we would celebrate the result and their bravery in taking risk. But again, what are they really risking? Something they didn’t have in the first place? I can’t help but think that contestants number one and two in the parable of the talents are operating under similar circumstances. And yet we congratulate them for their grit and determination, and pat them on the head for their stewardship.

This seems really strange because the third slave is the one who takes real risk here — and he actually knows he’s doing so. He’s the one who fears his master from the start — and seemingly with good reason. When the master returns, the slave explains why he chose to bury the talent he was given, saying: “Master, I knew that you were a harsh man, reaping where you did not sow, and gathering where you did not scatter seed; I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground. Here you have what is yours.” And these are pretty bold things for him to say.

We find out soon enough that he was right — his master is, in fact, a harsh man; he punishes the slave severely for what he sees as laziness. He chastises the slave for not having, at the very least, left the talent in the bank to earn interest (even though this would have a violation of Jewish law as given in the book of Deuteronomy — which tells us something about the master’s way of doing business). The master takes off, leaving his money to others and expecting (without actually saying so) that they will return it and then some when he comes back. So the master is harsh, he plays fast and loose with the rules, he reaps what he does not sow. The slave seems to be spot-on with his understanding of his master’s character. And so I have a hard time saying that the master perfectly represents God in this story.

But I wonder why the third slave chooses to protect his master’s fortune. Is it out of fear for his own well-being or of it is because of some kind of concern he has for his master? And would the third slave have been the clear and obvious hero of the this story if the first two slaves had actually lost all of the money they had been given? So many questions…

I have to say that the third slave — even though he is also not Christ-like in every respect — makes me think an awful lot about Jesus. He bucks the system, he sees the situation before him with perfect clarity, he senses the danger in the situation in which he finds himself and does what he sees as the right thing anyway.

He knows that both the master and the social system the master represents are unfair and dangerous;

he knows that he will be judged harshly and he still decides to protect all that he has been entrusted with — not for his own benefit, but for the benefit of those who don’t actually deserve it;

he takes all the risk with no expectation of reward.

And the system punishes him dearly for it.

Expect the unexpected — the less risky route becomes the more risky, the fearful becomes the courageous, the least among us becomes the greatest… I hope you can see where I am headed with this.

I know that the details don’t all line up perfectly here — Jesus’s parables are pretty good at throwing wrenches into whatever interpretation we try to put upon them. And every single time I read this one, I walk away scratching my head because my prior understanding of it is undermined in some way.

But what seems quite clear is this: Doing what we know in our hearts to be right is often dangerous. Following Christ’s example can put us on the wrong side of what those around us seem to value. Seeking the kingdom can be downright unsafe.

And so I’ll leave you to wrestle with the question that I posed earlier: Just how much are you really willing to risk for God?